By Thomas Davis, CRNA, MAE, DNAP candidate

follow@procrnatom on twitter

 

Disruptive behavior cuts a wide swath in the workplace and, left unchecked, it will kill the morale and productivity of a team.  Conduct that is viewed to be disruptive runs a spectrum from minor sarcastic comments to full-blown toxicity of a colleague whose ability to put a negative spin on just about anything is worthy of an Oscar.  A working definition of disruptive behavior is:  Any ongoing personal conduct that disturbs the work environment.  Lainie Peterson, contributing author to Chron, notes that “disruptive behavior kills group morale, drops team productivity, increases workplace stress, increases employee turnover and creates a negative reputation for the employer.”  The effects of disruptive behavior are potentially pervasive, and leaders have a vested interest in drawing a red line.

 

“An ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure.”

~Ben Franklin

 

 “Stay Out of Trouble…”

My mother liked to address my youthful indiscretions by saying, “It’s easier to stay out of trouble than to get out of trouble.”  In the workplace, those words of wisdom support the proactive approach of developing a system that attracts and hires workers who value collaboration and congeniality, rather than one that tolerates malignant behavior.

Recruiting.  You are not seeking a warm body to fill a position with your group, you want the right person.  Make sure that your job description touts collaborative teamwork that adheres to the mission, vision and values of the organization.  Use the JD to let applicants know not only what you want them to do, but also how you want them to do it. Making supportive teamwork a job requirement, puts you on solid ground should the need arise to address poor conduct of an employee in the future.

Hiring   Determining the right person for a job must include an interview format that includes a two-way dialogue about job expectations.  An interview technique that I have found to be particularly revealing is to provide the applicant with a list of the organization’s core values and discuss them during the interview.  Conclude the interview by saying, “if these values are not who you are, this is not your job.”  By discussing teamwork and values at interview, you further establish a solid foundation for addressing disruptive behavior should it arise.

Feedback   Schedule a one on one discussion with each new hire at the end of each of the first six months of their employment.  Each month, review the values that were discussed at interview and ask the person to relate their daily work to the organization’s values.  If negative feedback about the person’s behavior has been put forward by co-workers, give the employee a wide berth to answer to the accusations followed by a frank two-way discussion to clarify expectations.  After reinforcing your anticipation of supportive teamwork, ask for a re-commitment to the shared values of the group.

Teamwork.  Those who are already on the team deserve the same opportunity to discuss team values that you had with the job applicant.  Dedicate a team meeting to conversation about the core values of the organization and open the floor for your team members to identify behavior that would support the values.  Decisively tell the team, just as you did the applicant, “if these values do not represent who you are, this is not the right job for you.”

 

 “Get Out of Trouble.”

If hire-prevention hasn’t kept a bad actor from slipping into the ranks and general morale is suffering, it’s time to roll out the fire-hose.

Look for the cause.  Before you pull out the big guns and start firing, look for the cause of the disruptive behavior.  The person may be suffering unusual stress from satisfying the needs of a sick child or an infirmed elderly parent, or the worker may be experiencing critical financial woes causing internal stress that has been allowed to affect their external behavior.  Counsel your team member and look for options such as flexible work scheduling, or a leave of absence, to enable the person’s resolution of issues.

Give direct feedback.  Workers who disrupt the workplace by lack of personal restraint must be given a clear description of the problems they have created. Again, meet privately with the offender and provide an accurate review of the complaints lodged against the individual and precisely identify the consequences created for the team as a result the bad behavior.  If you are concerned for your personal safety or anticipate passive aggressive spin on your words, have a second person in attendance at the meeting.  Caution: Try not to create an environment in which the accused feels as if the boss is “ganging up.”

 

Be specific.  Giving negative feedback can be uncomfortable and it may be tempting to talk in generalities. …don’t.   In order to ensure that behavior changes, you need to be specific and define your expectations.  Be your confident self as you state, “When you do…, it has this effect…”  If you’re dealing with and angry bird, point out the far-reaching effects on those other than their target. Those who witness the encounter, either patients or colleagues, become collateral damage of the disruptive behavior.

Set boundaries.  After establishing the behavior that is to be eliminated, move on to discussing the desired behavior.  Review the mission, vision and values of the organization and make it clear as to how the behavior did not support the core values.  Challenge the person to describe how they might have handled a situation differently had they kept the core values in mind.  Make it clear that the worker’s behavior moving forward must align with core values and that deviation will mandate dismissal from the team. End the session by setting dates for two follow-up sessions.

 

Follow-up.  If behavior has changed, use the first follow-up session to extend kudos and encouragement. Give feedback from the team to promote a feeling of inclusion. If progress has been made but more work is required, congratulate the improvement and have the person identify additional measures that will continue the momentum.  If no progress has been made, move forward with termination.

 

A disruptive team member can create a very uncomfortable environment for both leader and co-worker.  Emotions run high in the healthcare workplace inherently and the work environment certainly doesn’t need the friction created by bad behavior within the team.  Rather than avoiding confrontation, see bad behavior as an opportunity to implement decisive leadership. In the process you will eliminate the disturbing personal conduct and earn respect.  Your failure to act with authority will allow the obstructive behavior to weave itself into the fabric of the team, creating a negative culture that will eventually require outside intervention.

Hire congenial, collaborative people and don’t hesitate to deal with disruptive employees you inherited.   Design a system that has zero tolerance for disruptive behavior, and you can stay out of trouble before you get in trouble.  Both my mother and Ben were right.

 

Tom is a noted author, enthusiastic speaker, committed leadership developer and superb clinical anesthetist.   Contact tom@prosynex.com to book a speaking engagement.